The complex nature of Australian supply chains is increasing the knowledge divide between livestock producers and end consumers on animal welfare practices and outcomes, posing significant challenges for the future sustainability and profitability of Australia’s beef industry.
That’s according to Thomas Green, 2019 Nuffield Scholar and general manager of Thomas Foods International’s Iranda Beef Feedlot in South Australia, who investigated the complexity of animal welfare in livestock production with a focus on the beef feedlot industry.
Travelling across North and South America, the European Union and Africa, Mr Green visited and interviewed industry experts, universities, research institutions, individual enterprises, corporate agricultural businesses, and industry service providers, to better understand different perspectives concerning animal welfare in Australian agriculture.
In his report released today, Mr Green said animal welfare was a highly emotive and subjective topic, with consumers becoming increasingly concerned with how their food is produced.
“Across my Nuffield Scholarship, I visited leading producers and agricultural businesses that have been able to drive high welfare outcomes and greater transparency and public reputations for their enterprises,” Mr Green said.
He visited Cactus Feeders in Texas and Kansas in the US, a large employee-owned commercial agricultural business that operates ten feedlots and markets more than one million grainfed cattle annually.
“Cactus has become an industry leader, focussing on utilising new technologies to produce protein in a more sustainable and efficient manner which they believe is key to beef remaining an affordable and accessible form of protein,” Mr Green said.
“Regularly asked to represent the American commercial beef industry, Cactus Feeders is transparent with end-consumers and industry by hosting chefs, students, politicians, industry executives and journalists at feedlots to give them an opportunity to see how the beef industry works first-hand.”
Mr Green said Australian producers show a high level of care and skill with livestock management, which combined with new technologies has seen rapid increases in production efficiencies.
“These production efficiencies combined with evolving consumer expectations, has resulted in greater questioning around the ethics of the livestock production industry,” he said.
“There is growing recognition of this among livestock producers in Australia’s red meat sector, which is creating uncertainty and nervousness around the future sustainability of their own businesses.
“The challenge for industry lies in the growing knowledge gaps on each end of the supply chain and perceptions surrounding a lack of transparency, which is reducing the level of understanding and respect between producer and consumer.
“Greater transparency is needed across industry supply chains to increase consumer support. Driving positive animal welfare outcomes and environmental sustainability should be central to industry direction, strategy and communication.”
Mr Green said the industry’s complex supply chains were designed to extract maximum financial value, offering little room for enterprises to establish complete transparency between producer and consumer.
“Australia’s livestock industry has struggled to keep abreast of public concern and has been consistently forced to defend current practices rather than spending resources on industry improvements and communicating positive, informative messages to consumers.”
Traditionally, each red meat industry had been primarily concerned with protecting its own interests, rather than building a greater understanding of the role they play in maintaining a sustainable supply chain.
“A more transparent and collaborative approach is needed to move forward with industry reform,” Mr Green said.
Travelling in Switzerland, he visited Mays’ Burehof, a mixed cattle and pig livestock operation, which, supported by strong government legislation, has driven high animal welfare outcomes and consumer support.
“The Mays have placed a strong emphasis on whole-life animal welfare and environmental sustainability and found great business success by locally slaughtering and marketing directly to local restaurants and catering businesses,” Mr Green said.
“Throughout summer, cows and calves graze in pasture before being confined through winter to protect the countryside and animals from exposure to the elements. During this period, all needs are met through well-designed facilities and high levels of care from animal attendants.”
Australia’s feedlot industry is recognised as a leader in Australian agriculture in terms of its proactive quality assurance programs and producer engagement, but Mr Green said an industry is only as sustainable as every stakeholder across the entire supply chain.
“Australian meat is already known for its quality and consistency, and there exists a great platform for producers and industry bodies to build on. It is imperative that we also have a supply chain that all stakeholders can be confident in,” he said.
Thomas Green’s Nuffield Scholarship was supported by Rabobank.