Live Export

Japan suspends cattle imports from Australia

James Nason, 02/06/2016

JAPAN has suspended live cattle imports from Australia.

The dramatic move comes after a consignment of young dairy heifers air-freighted from Victoria last week allegedly tested positive to Bovine Johne’s Disease in quarantine in Japan.

It is understood the heifers tested negative to BJD before leaving Australia.

Australian Government and industry leaders confirmed news of the ban to Beef Central this morning.

Australian-bred F1 Wagyu cattle being fed in a Japanese feedlot after live export

Australian-bred F1 Wagyu cattle being fed in a Japanese feedlot after live export

While the cattle involved are Holstein heifers exported under a breeding protocol, the temporary suspension also affects Australia’s much larger Wagyu feeder cattle  trade to Japan, which operates under a separate feeder/slaughter cattle protocol.

The tests used to screen for Johne’s disease in quarantine (the Elisa blood test and the PCA DNA tests) are known to produce false-positives and false negatives, with false-results particularly prevalent in younger animals.

Dairy heifers vaccinated with the Silirum vaccine can also give false positive tests to both Johne’s and Tuberculosis.

Uncertainty still surrounds the accuracy and reliability of the testing procedures used by Japan to justify the trade ban.

Johne’s is a wasting disease of cattle that has no known cure. It can be found in many species in the natural environment, is endemic in most countries of the world, including Japan, and is considered by many to be ineradicable.

Japan is one of the very few countries still attempting to eradicate Johne’s from its national herd, which is why it requires imported cattle to be tested for Johne’s disease.

Japan had the option of suspending imports from the individual property or properties that supplied the dairy heifers in the consignment, but has taken the more extreme step of suspending all cattle imports from Australia.

Australia exports a small number of Holstein heifers to Japan each year.

However its major export cattle trade to the market involves the annual shipment of around 10,000 8-12 month old, 280-300kg Wagyu F1 and Fullblood feeder steers and heifers in shipments of 1000 head per month exported from Brisbane. The reliable trade has existed for many years.

Beef Central understands that a consignment of 1000 Wagyu export steers and heifers destined for Japan is currently being held in pre-export quarantine and was due to be shipped to the market in mid-June.

There is no indication yet as to how long the suspension may last.

A spokesperson for the Department of Agriculture confirmed to Beef Central today that the Japanese authorities had announced that they will temporarily stop accepting feeder and breeder cattle from Australia in response to a number of cattle testing positive for Johne’s disease in post arrival quarantine.

“The Department is investigating, to confirm that cattle were prepared according to the importing country requirements,” the spokesperson said.

”The Department is working closely with the Japanese authorities on this issue.”

The process of exporting cattle to Japan under the breeding cattle protocol requires careful selection of properties from which cattle can be sourced. Heifers must be tested twice for BJD before they can approved for export to Japan.

In a statement to Beef Central this morning Australian Livestock Exporters Council chief executive officer Alison Penfold said industry was aware that Japan has found “a small number of test positive results relating to BJD within a consignment of breeding livestock exported to the market in May.”

“We understand that the relevant Japanese Ministry has placed a temporarily suspension on the import of cattle from Australia.

“Japan is sensitive about BJD and is undertaking an eradication program.  However, BJD has a world-wide distribution and is likely to be present in all countries to which Australia exports livestock,” she said.

“All animals exported from Australia must meet strict importing country requirements and be certified as eligible to receive an Australian Government health certificate, attesting to their health status.  The consignment was certified under these conditions.

The government-to-government agreed health conditions between Australia and Japan includes detailed testing requirements for a range of diseases. BJD is one of the diseases tested.

“ALEC understands that all animals remain in quarantine in Japan – as per standard importing arrangements – and are being well cared for,” Ms Penfold said.

“There are government-to-government discussions underway and industry supports this process. We await advice on the outcomes of these discussions.

“Industry will work with Government to ensure Australia’s biosecurity and internationally recognised animal health status is preserved. Australian cattle have an excellent health status and the prevalence of BJD in Australia is very low by world standards.

“Industry has great confidence in the integrity of our testing systems and technology – particularly as the test for the disease in question (BJD) is undertaken by internationally recognised laboratories using world leading technology,” she said.

“We are not aware of any food safety or health risks.”

 

Leave a Reply to Garry Hedger Cancel Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Your comment will not appear until it has been moderated.
Contributions that contravene our Comments Policy will not be published.

Comments

  1. Mark morawitz, 04/06/2016

    It’s obvious the relevant Japanese ministry hasn’t been educated or enlightened to the pinpoint accuracy of the e-nlis and the water tight protocol provided by lpa. If they did perhaps only the properties of origin would be temporarily suspended and not two whole sectors within an industry. Maybe the original mla and dep of ag staff that that did the ( all you need is a pair of pliers and buttons ) field days should go on a whirlwind speaking tour of one of our largest trading partners and allay the fear. Once again as I order my e-tags this year I’ll get that warm feeling inside knowing I’ve played my part in keeping the doors of international trade open.

  2. Sarah P, 04/06/2016

    These are an interesting read but the issue in point is about the importing country’s requirements not our domestic BJD policies.

  3. Jonathan Spence, 03/06/2016

    I along with many in our industry applaude your comments Don Lawson . In recent years we have watched many seed stock operations vacate the MAP program as they have seen plenty of red tape , costs and few benefits except perhaps better education of how to manage prevention of spread of Johnes disease . Yet in our state ( South Australia) industry has been lobbied by a cattle advisory group previously made up of stud breeders and academics seemingly all with a desire to enter a profession of agri politics that have suggested all beef producers pay a levy to subsidise such programs . Of course they would waive such a levy on the poor cousin dairy farmers in southern Aust, even though the large majority instance of Johnes disease is born and spread in dairy herds . !!!! No wonder you have an OAM Don , keep up the good work .

  4. Garry Hedger, 03/06/2016

    Don Lawson, your comment was well written and very true. I and many others have been led to believe that there was no point in testing stock under 2 years of age as the disease was not detectable at this stage. So as usual with this hole program it appears no one knows what’s going on it’s just been made up as it goes along.

  5. don lawson oam, 03/06/2016

    Finally its out in the public areana how flawed and unreliable the testing and policies on Johnes has been. We have had 2 senate inquiries and 1 state government inquiry over the last 19 years into JOHNES and still the government vets feast on it to keep there jobs.
    These policies have resulted in enormous damage to producers including a number of suicides. Just look at the damage in Queensland to about 160 plus stations over just 3 animals that allegedly tested positive to the bison strain where was the compensation they were promised by minister McVeigh.

    We need an open judicial inquiry into the Johnes disaster so that the vets behind this can be examined publicly to justify there professional advice.

    Animal Health Australia needs to explain the justification for the MAP which now has 360 herds in the scheme, when there is about 1000 stud herds and thousands of commercial beef enterprises not tested. What is the cost of such a scheme with so few producers in it, and what are the benefits to the industry that is funding this at great cost?

Get Beef Central's news headlines emailed to you -
FREE!