News

ALEC calls out activists and politicians on MV Bahija claims

Beef Central 01/02/2024

The MV Bahijah in Fremantle in 2018 (Bahnfrend – CC BY-SA 4.0 DEED)

AUSTRALIAN Livestock Exporters’ Council chief executive officer Mark Harvey-Sutton has called out activist groups and politicians on claims they have made about the conditions onboard the MV Bahijah .

“Once again, activists are spreading lies to further their own cause and it’s time it was called out” said Mr Harvey-Sutton.

The MV Bahija docked in Fremantle this morning to refill with fodder and wait for a Government decision on a proposal to re-export the ship to Israel.

Last night two independent veterinarians attended the vessel and reported that the livestock remain in good health and there is no evidence of any significant health or welfare concerns.

“While industry has worked diligently with the Australian Government to resolve this issue in the full knowledge that there are processes and procedures to handle circumstances such as these, we, as an industry, have had to endure intolerable lies about what is going on – all from people that have never set foot on a livestock vessel once in their lives.

“Last night I saw a representative of the RSPCA on television, when asked what conditions were like on the vessel, describing the most horrid conditions without a scrap of evidence to support their claims. Even at one point describing Western Australian farmers as having ‘disgusting’ views about the conditions on board – well how the hell would the RSPCA know?

“Despite repeated invitations to RSPCA to go on a vessel tour they have never once accepted.”

Mr Harvey-Sutton said it was appalling that such ludicrous claims were being made without first-hand evidence.

“The same goes for Labor backbencher Josh Wilson, who called on people to come and protest the industry, unprofessionally describing it as ‘rotten the core’, yet the best that could be mustered is 100 people with nothing better to do standing on the wharf – representing 0.004pc of the population of Perth.

“This hardly seems the “community backlash” that those opposed to the trade cling to when seeking to justify banning live exports, all the while clutching at clickbait surveys and push-polling that harvest outcomes in their favour as evidence.”

Mr Wilson also claimed that the trade is “virtually defunct” – which Mr Harvey-Sutton said was false given sheep volumes have increased by 40pc and the Saudia Arabia market has just reopened, and one that he should have the courage to say to the faces of the thousands of farmers in Western Australia who make a living from it.

Mr Harvey-Sutton said all these parties are cynically viewing this as an opportunity to further Australian Government’s ill-informed policy to phase out the industry. A policy that even the Premier of Western Australia has said should be reconsidered demonstrating his strong support for the live export industry and Western Australian Farmers.

“While these activists are basking in their five minutes of fame, they are conveniently ignoring the fact this vessel returning has its roots in a very serious issue that is affecting our country’s economy and contributing to the cost-of-living pressure as well – attacks by Houthi rebels in the Red Sea. This issue must always be viewed in the context that this vessel had right to navigate this route and it was prevented from doing so.”

“By pushing these mistruths, these groups are proving they are no friends of the Australian community, and they are certainly no friends of the thousands of hard-working people employed by agriculture. But why let the truth get in the way of facts?”

Source: ALEC

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

HAVE YOUR SAY

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Your comment will not appear until it has been moderated.
Contributions that contravene our Comments Policy will not be published.

Comments

  1. John Armstrong, 06/02/2024

    A good reply to the activists, but where will it be published except for Beef Central whose circulation (with respect) would be only to the converted, I would assume? I.E. Not just left on the out tray as a media release?

  2. Dr Peter Arnold, 06/02/2024

    Been and seen the sheep and cattle on the ship at Fremantle. They are perfectly ok. Plenty of food water ventilation and space. Better than being on a farm. There needs to be a logical outcome. Export them or off load them. Either is ok. Doing nothing is not. The ship itself is a perfect quarantine station. Keep Greenies and inexperienced people away. I am experienced.

  3. michael burgis, 05/02/2024

    Great story. Activist are given too much air time to promote their BS. We need to maintain as many markets as possible for all our exports.

  4. Jeff Forster, 03/02/2024

    Time will come and this rabble of ah’s will have nothing to eat except for “Green Tablets”.
    No matter, …… they probably won’t bother to do the research into what they consist of ?.
    Just keep banging the rural can.
    JSM

Get Beef Central's news headlines emailed to you -
FREE!